Advanced search
1 file | 2.10 MB Add to list

Why do they do it? Explaining local governments’ choices of service delivery modes

(2022)
Author
Promoter
(UGent)
Organization
Abstract
While local governments have historically provided citizens with public services through in-house service delivery using their own employees and resources, in the past few decades, the array of alternative service delivery modes available to local governments has increased dramatically. Studies have found that today the default approach in many countries is the choice of local alternative service delivery modes, i.e. local governments rely on ‘external’ providers in service delivery rather than on in-house service delivery. This has spurred scholars to investigate why local governments choose alternative service delivery modes or externalise service delivery. Scholars generally point to the relevance of financial, economic efficiency and political-ideological drivers, i.e. focused on municipal-level and service-level drivers. This dissertation examines the drivers of these choices in a Flemish context and focuses on the elderly care sector and the household waste management sector. Doing so, we rely on a large number of data of various kinds such as government documents and semi-structured interviews with politicians, civil servants and not-for-profit partners. After a general introduction and problem statement, Chapter 1 sets the scene by means of a conceptual and theoretical outline with a discussion on the most prominent evolutions within the literature. We find that, despite the continuing interest of scholars in investigating the issue, literature still presents inconclusive and divergent research findings. In our opinion, two prominent issues remain a challenge in current research, related to both theoretical underpinnings of the predominant body of literature (i.e. current research is largely based on rational choice theory) as methodological in nature (i.e. many research efforts fail in capturing choices of service delivery modes in and over time and revealing their true underlying drivers). This dissertation aims at contributing to the body of knowledge by taking up the abovementioned theoretical and methodological gauntlet in the empirical parts (Chapters 3, 4 and 5). Based on a multiple-case study design, we find that financial and economic efficiency factors are important drivers of externalisation, while the impact of political ideology impacts the choice of PPP (Chapter 3). While entailing a satisfying explanation for the studied choices of service delivery modes in the elderly care sector in Chapter 3, we expand the framework both theoretically (by introducing the concept of coercive isomorphism) and methodologically (by employing a longitudinal multiple-case study design) in Chapter 4. Focusing on household waste collection, we show that these factors have to be studied in relation to (the evolution of) coercive pressures not only on the service delivery mode itself (direct), but also on the service characteristics (indirect). Bringing in the influence of central governmental policy, and moving beyond merely looking at municipal-level and service-level factors, on these choices, thus, proves to be essential in understanding the drivers of these choices. In chapter 5, focusing on household waste processing and household waste collection, we theoretically innovate by seeking inspiration in historical institutionalism to improve our understanding of local service delivery modes. We find that choices are highly influenced by path dependent processes and that they are structured and shaped by the confluence of a limited number of critical junctures generated by mostly exogenous factors while only in some cases combined with endogenous factors. Conclusively, this dissertation provides evidence that financial and economic efficiency drivers are, indeed, important factors in explaining choices of service delivery modes. While we did not find evidence of political-ideological drivers on choices of service delivery modes in the household waste management sector, they do appear to impact the choice for PPP in the service delivery of elderly care centres. This said, we showed that in order to fully understand why local governments choose certain service delivery modes, one should account for the impact of central governmental policy and pay attention to the temporal dimension. One overarching important finding in this dissertation is that research has potentially been overstressing endogenous determinants (at the expense of exogenous determinants) and overestimating the discretionary power of local governments in making these choices. Further, this dissertation indicates that findings from the international literature are not ipso facto generalisable to the context of Flanders, which is still characterised by a more European Napoleonic tradition, i.e. powerful, centralised bureaucracy and functionally rather weak local governments. Accordingly, future research could further undertake more comparative endeavours by, for example, deliberately choosing to research the topic in regions and countries with similar or dissimilar central-local relations or other traditions and starting positions in service areas. Key in this should be firstly assessing the actual autonomy of local governments in making these choices prior to turning to explain their choices.
Keywords
local government, service delivery mode, local public services

Downloads

  • (...).pdf
    • full text (Published version)
    • |
    • UGent only (changes to open access on 2027-09-12)
    • |
    • PDF
    • |
    • 2.10 MB

Citation

Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:

MLA
Vos, David. Why Do They Do It? Explaining Local Governments’ Choices of Service Delivery Modes. Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, 2022.
APA
Vos, D. (2022). Why do they do it? Explaining local governments’ choices of service delivery modes. Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Ghent, Belgium.
Chicago author-date
Vos, David. 2022. “Why Do They Do It? Explaining Local Governments’ Choices of Service Delivery Modes.” Ghent, Belgium: Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration.
Chicago author-date (all authors)
Vos, David. 2022. “Why Do They Do It? Explaining Local Governments’ Choices of Service Delivery Modes.” Ghent, Belgium: Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration.
Vancouver
1.
Vos D. Why do they do it? Explaining local governments’ choices of service delivery modes. [Ghent, Belgium]: Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration; 2022.
IEEE
[1]
D. Vos, “Why do they do it? Explaining local governments’ choices of service delivery modes,” Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, Ghent, Belgium, 2022.
@phdthesis{8766414,
  abstract     = {{While local governments have historically provided citizens with public services through in-house service delivery using their own employees and resources, in the past few decades, the array of alternative service delivery modes available to local governments has increased dramatically. Studies have found that today the default approach in many countries is the choice of local alternative service delivery modes, i.e. local governments rely on ‘external’ providers in service delivery rather than on in-house service delivery. This has spurred scholars to investigate why local governments choose alternative service delivery modes or externalise service delivery. Scholars generally point to the relevance of financial, economic efficiency and political-ideological drivers, i.e. focused on municipal-level and service-level drivers. This dissertation examines the drivers of these choices in a Flemish context and focuses on the elderly care sector and the household waste management sector. Doing so, we rely on a large number of data of various kinds such as government documents and semi-structured interviews with politicians, civil servants and not-for-profit partners.

After a general introduction and problem statement, Chapter 1 sets the scene by means of a conceptual and theoretical outline with a discussion on the most prominent evolutions within the literature. We find that, despite the continuing interest of scholars in investigating the issue, literature still presents inconclusive and divergent research findings. In our opinion, two prominent issues remain a challenge in current research, related to both theoretical underpinnings of the predominant body of literature (i.e. current research is largely based on rational choice theory) as methodological in nature (i.e. many research efforts fail in capturing choices of service delivery modes in and over time and revealing their true underlying drivers). This dissertation aims at contributing to the body of knowledge by taking up the abovementioned theoretical and methodological gauntlet in the empirical parts (Chapters 3, 4 and 5). Based on a multiple-case study design, we find that financial and economic efficiency factors are important drivers of externalisation, while the impact of political ideology impacts the choice of PPP (Chapter 3). While entailing a satisfying explanation for the studied choices of service delivery modes in the elderly care sector in Chapter 3, we expand the framework both theoretically (by introducing the concept of coercive isomorphism) and methodologically (by employing a longitudinal multiple-case study design) in Chapter 4. Focusing on household waste collection, we show that these factors have to be studied in relation to (the evolution of) coercive pressures not only on the service delivery mode itself (direct), but also on the service characteristics (indirect). Bringing in the influence of central governmental policy, and moving beyond merely looking at municipal-level and service-level factors, on these choices, thus, proves to be essential in understanding the drivers of these choices. In chapter 5, focusing on household waste processing and household waste collection, we theoretically innovate by seeking inspiration in historical institutionalism to improve our understanding of local service delivery modes. We find that choices are highly influenced by path dependent processes and that they are structured and shaped by the confluence of a limited number of critical junctures generated by mostly exogenous factors while only in some cases combined with endogenous factors.

Conclusively, this dissertation provides evidence that financial and economic efficiency drivers are, indeed, important factors in explaining choices of service delivery modes. While we did not find evidence of political-ideological drivers on choices of service delivery modes in the household waste management sector, they do appear to impact the choice for PPP in the service delivery of elderly care centres. This said, we showed that in order to fully understand why local governments choose certain service delivery modes, one should account for the impact of central governmental policy and pay attention to the temporal dimension. One overarching important finding in this dissertation is that research has potentially been overstressing endogenous determinants (at the expense of exogenous determinants) and overestimating the discretionary power of local governments in making these choices. Further, this dissertation indicates that findings from the international literature are not ipso facto generalisable to the context of Flanders, which is still characterised by a more European Napoleonic tradition, i.e. powerful, centralised bureaucracy and functionally rather weak local governments. Accordingly, future research could further undertake more comparative endeavours by, for example, deliberately choosing to research the topic in regions and countries with similar or dissimilar central-local relations or other traditions and starting positions in service areas. Key in this should be firstly assessing the actual autonomy of local governments in making these choices prior to turning to explain their choices.}},
  author       = {{Vos, David}},
  keywords     = {{local government,service delivery mode,local public services}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  pages        = {{208}},
  publisher    = {{Ghent University. Faculty of Economics and Business Administration}},
  school       = {{Ghent University}},
  title        = {{Why do they do it? Explaining local governments’ choices of service delivery modes}},
  year         = {{2022}},
}