Advanced search
1 file | 824.55 KB Add to list

How to overcome political and legal barriers to the implementation of a drug consumption room : an application of the policy agenda framework to the Belgian situation

Author
Organization
Abstract
Background: For more than 30 years, drug consumption rooms (DCRs) have been implemented in Western countries. DCRs are supported by a large body of evidence about public safety and public health effectiveness. However, a political consensus has never been achieved in Belgium on amending the existing law that explicitly penalises the supply of a room for facilitating drug use. Despite this adverse legal and policy framework, a DCR opened in the city of Liège in 2018. In this case report, we applied the theoretical framework proposed by Shiffman and Smith for policy agenda setting, in order to describe and assess how political and legal barriers were overcome in the process of opening the DCR. Case presentation: For some years, fieldworkers and some city policymakers argued for DCR implementation in Belgium, but without gaining the support of the national authorities, mainly for ideological reasons. In order to address this debate, a feasibility study of DCR implementation in Belgian cities was commissioned. At the national level, an institutional debate took place about the political responsibility for DCRs as a public health intervention, as health care is mainly a matter of regional policy. The lack of consensus led to a situation of political deadlock. Meanwhile, the publication of the study report and the context of local elections offered an opportunity for Liège authorities to reignite the local debate on DCRs. At the local level, law enforcement, care professionals, residents, users, and the press were all involved in the implementation process. Therefore, a local consensus was formed and despite the absence of any national legal change, the DCR opened 1 month before the local elections. It has been working without major medical or legal incident since then. Incidentally, the mayor of Liège was re-elected. Conclusions: Although the lack of a legal framework may engender instability and affect longer-term effectiveness, the DCR implementation in Liège was successful and was based on a local consensus and effective communication rather than on an appropriate legal framework. The experience provides lessons for other cities that are considering opening a DCR despite an adverse legal and political context.
Keywords
Drug consumption room, Implementation, Drug policy, SAFER INJECTION FACILITY, GLOBAL HEALTH, PRIORITY, USERS, SERVICES, IMPACT

Downloads

  • Smith DCR Belgium.pdf
    • full text (Published version)
    • |
    • open access
    • |
    • PDF
    • |
    • 824.55 KB

Citation

Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:

MLA
Smith, Pierre, et al. “How to Overcome Political and Legal Barriers to the Implementation of a Drug Consumption Room : An Application of the Policy Agenda Framework to the Belgian Situation.” ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE, vol. 14, no. 1, 2019, doi:10.1186/s13722-019-0169-x.
APA
Smith, P., Favril, L., Delhauteur, D., Vander Laenen, F., & Nicaise, P. (2019). How to overcome political and legal barriers to the implementation of a drug consumption room : an application of the policy agenda framework to the Belgian situation. ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE, 14(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13722-019-0169-x
Chicago author-date
Smith, Pierre, Louis Favril, Dominique Delhauteur, Freya Vander Laenen, and Pablo Nicaise. 2019. “How to Overcome Political and Legal Barriers to the Implementation of a Drug Consumption Room : An Application of the Policy Agenda Framework to the Belgian Situation.” ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE 14 (1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13722-019-0169-x.
Chicago author-date (all authors)
Smith, Pierre, Louis Favril, Dominique Delhauteur, Freya Vander Laenen, and Pablo Nicaise. 2019. “How to Overcome Political and Legal Barriers to the Implementation of a Drug Consumption Room : An Application of the Policy Agenda Framework to the Belgian Situation.” ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE 14 (1). doi:10.1186/s13722-019-0169-x.
Vancouver
1.
Smith P, Favril L, Delhauteur D, Vander Laenen F, Nicaise P. How to overcome political and legal barriers to the implementation of a drug consumption room : an application of the policy agenda framework to the Belgian situation. ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE. 2019;14(1).
IEEE
[1]
P. Smith, L. Favril, D. Delhauteur, F. Vander Laenen, and P. Nicaise, “How to overcome political and legal barriers to the implementation of a drug consumption room : an application of the policy agenda framework to the Belgian situation,” ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE, vol. 14, no. 1, 2019.
@article{8634124,
  abstract     = {Background: For more than 30 years, drug consumption rooms (DCRs) have been implemented in Western countries. DCRs are supported by a large body of evidence about public safety and public health effectiveness. However, a political consensus has never been achieved in Belgium on amending the existing law that explicitly penalises the supply of a room for facilitating drug use. Despite this adverse legal and policy framework, a DCR opened in the city of Liège in 2018. In this case report, we applied the theoretical framework proposed by Shiffman and Smith for policy agenda setting, in order to describe and assess how political and legal barriers were overcome in the process of opening the DCR. Case presentation: For some years, fieldworkers and some city policymakers argued for DCR implementation in Belgium, but without gaining the support of the national authorities, mainly for ideological reasons. In order to address this debate, a feasibility study of DCR implementation in Belgian cities was commissioned. At the national level, an institutional debate took place about the political responsibility for DCRs as a public health intervention, as health care is mainly a matter of regional policy. The lack of consensus led to a situation of political deadlock. Meanwhile, the publication of the study report and the context of local elections offered an opportunity for Liège authorities to reignite the local debate on DCRs. At the local level, law enforcement, care professionals, residents, users, and the press were all involved in the implementation process. Therefore, a local consensus was formed and despite the absence of any national legal change, the DCR opened 1 month before the local elections. It has been working without major medical or legal incident since then. Incidentally, the mayor of Liège was re-elected. Conclusions: Although the lack of a legal framework may engender instability and affect longer-term effectiveness, the DCR implementation in Liège was successful and was based on a local consensus and effective communication rather than on an appropriate legal framework. The experience provides lessons for other cities that are considering opening a DCR despite an adverse legal and political context.},
  articleno    = {40},
  author       = {Smith, Pierre and Favril, Louis and Delhauteur, Dominique and Vander Laenen, Freya and Nicaise, Pablo},
  issn         = {1940-0640},
  journal      = {ADDICTION SCIENCE & CLINICAL PRACTICE},
  keywords     = {Drug consumption room,Implementation,Drug policy,SAFER INJECTION FACILITY,GLOBAL HEALTH,PRIORITY,USERS,SERVICES,IMPACT},
  language     = {eng},
  number       = {1},
  pages        = {9},
  title        = {How to overcome political and legal barriers to the implementation of a drug consumption room : an application of the policy agenda framework to the Belgian situation},
  url          = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13722-019-0169-x},
  volume       = {14},
  year         = {2019},
}

Altmetric
View in Altmetric
Web of Science
Times cited: