Advanced search
1 file | 3.31 MB Add to list

Monitoring of marine nematode communities through 18S rRNA metabarcoding as a sensitive alternative to morphology

Author
Organization
Abstract
Nematodes are suitable indicators for environmental perturbations because their distribution is closely linked to sediment characteristics. To evaluate whether DNA-based approaches can complement or even outperform morphology-based monitoring, careful evaluation of both approaches is needed using field samples that clearly differ in environmental parameters. We compared metabarcoding, targeting the 18S rRNA and COI genes, with morphological identification of the nematode communities in three different land use areas (aquaculture, industry and nature reserve) in Vietnamese mangroves. The areas differed in heavy metal and nitrate content and granulometry. We additionally generated reference Sanger sequences from these areas in order to improve the genus and species level assignments of the metabarcode data. We compared nematode densities, species and genus composition and diversity estimates, and nematode specific indices in relation to the environmental differences between areas. Our results show that multivariate patterns were similar between the three approaches, while the 18S rRNA metabarcoding dataset best described changes in diversity and community composition in relation to the environmental differences in our sites. The taxonomic composition of the samples was strikingly different depending on the method and less taxa were detected using DNA based methods than the morphology-based method. We show that this is mainly attributed to a lack of entries in the reference databases. The 18S rRNA metabarcoding approach provides a reliable and fast way to screen for environmental changes. Nevertheless, when we also want to understand those changes, the ecological and biological information linked to taxonomy remain essential. We therefore advocate that the addition of new reference sequences from vouchered specimens to reference databases should be an essential part of every metabarcoding study.
Keywords
Nematodes, Morphological identification, Metabarcoding, 18S rRNA and COI genes, Mangrove, ECOLOGICAL QUALITY STATUS, POPULATION GENETIC-STRUCTURE, DNA, DIVERSITY, SEQUENCES, MEIOFAUNA, SEDIMENT, PATTERNS, IDENTIFICATION, ASSEMBLAGES

Downloads

  • (...).pdf
    • full text
    • |
    • UGent only
    • |
    • PDF
    • |
    • 3.31 MB

Citation

Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:

MLA
Tytgat, Bjorn, et al. “Monitoring of Marine Nematode Communities through 18S RRNA Metabarcoding as a Sensitive Alternative to Morphology.” ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS, vol. 107, 2019.
APA
Tytgat, B., Nguyen, D. T., Nguyen, T. X. P., Pham, T. M., Long, P. K., Vanreusel, A., & Derycke, S. (2019). Monitoring of marine nematode communities through 18S rRNA metabarcoding as a sensitive alternative to morphology. ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS, 107.
Chicago author-date
Tytgat, Bjorn, Dinh Tu Nguyen, Thi Xuan Phuong Nguyen, Thi Man Pham, Phan Ke Long, Ann Vanreusel, and Sofie Derycke. 2019. “Monitoring of Marine Nematode Communities through 18S RRNA Metabarcoding as a Sensitive Alternative to Morphology.” ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS 107.
Chicago author-date (all authors)
Tytgat, Bjorn, Dinh Tu Nguyen, Thi Xuan Phuong Nguyen, Thi Man Pham, Phan Ke Long, Ann Vanreusel, and Sofie Derycke. 2019. “Monitoring of Marine Nematode Communities through 18S RRNA Metabarcoding as a Sensitive Alternative to Morphology.” ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS 107.
Vancouver
1.
Tytgat B, Nguyen DT, Nguyen TXP, Pham TM, Long PK, Vanreusel A, et al. Monitoring of marine nematode communities through 18S rRNA metabarcoding as a sensitive alternative to morphology. ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS. 2019;107.
IEEE
[1]
B. Tytgat et al., “Monitoring of marine nematode communities through 18S rRNA metabarcoding as a sensitive alternative to morphology,” ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS, vol. 107, 2019.
@article{8630373,
  abstract     = {Nematodes are suitable indicators for environmental perturbations because their distribution is closely linked to sediment characteristics. To evaluate whether DNA-based approaches can complement or even outperform morphology-based monitoring, careful evaluation of both approaches is needed using field samples that clearly differ in environmental parameters. 
We compared metabarcoding, targeting the 18S rRNA and COI genes, with morphological identification of the nematode communities in three different land use areas (aquaculture, industry and nature reserve) in Vietnamese mangroves. The areas differed in heavy metal and nitrate content and granulometry. We additionally generated reference Sanger sequences from these areas in order to improve the genus and species level assignments of the metabarcode data. We compared nematode densities, species and genus composition and diversity estimates, and nematode specific indices in relation to the environmental differences between areas. 
Our results show that multivariate patterns were similar between the three approaches, while the 18S rRNA metabarcoding dataset best described changes in diversity and community composition in relation to the environmental differences in our sites. The taxonomic composition of the samples was strikingly different depending on the method and less taxa were detected using DNA based methods than the morphology-based method. We show that this is mainly attributed to a lack of entries in the reference databases. 
The 18S rRNA metabarcoding approach provides a reliable and fast way to screen for environmental changes. Nevertheless, when we also want to understand those changes, the ecological and biological information linked to taxonomy remain essential. We therefore advocate that the addition of new reference sequences from vouchered specimens to reference databases should be an essential part of every metabarcoding study.},
  articleno    = {105554},
  author       = {Tytgat, Bjorn and Nguyen, Dinh Tu and Nguyen, Thi Xuan Phuong and Pham, Thi Man and Long, Phan Ke and Vanreusel, Ann and Derycke, Sofie},
  issn         = {1470-160X},
  journal      = {ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS},
  keywords     = {Nematodes,Morphological identification,Metabarcoding,18S rRNA and COI genes,Mangrove,ECOLOGICAL QUALITY STATUS,POPULATION GENETIC-STRUCTURE,DNA,DIVERSITY,SEQUENCES,MEIOFAUNA,SEDIMENT,PATTERNS,IDENTIFICATION,ASSEMBLAGES},
  language     = {eng},
  pages        = {15},
  title        = {Monitoring of marine nematode communities through 18S rRNA metabarcoding as a sensitive alternative to morphology},
  url          = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2019.105554},
  volume       = {107},
  year         = {2019},
}

Altmetric
View in Altmetric
Web of Science
Times cited: