Ghent University Academic Bibliography

Advanced

Pauli's idea of the Neutrino: how models in physics allow to revive old ideas for new proposes

Tjerk Gauderis UGent (2014) Model-based reasoning in science and technology : theoretical and cognitive issues. In SAPERE p.449-461
abstract
Models have proven themselves to be the key catalyst of many new ideas in science. However, it is not yet fully clarified why models can fulfill such an important heuristic role. The two main reasons stated in the literature – the mental simulation of various scenarios and the wide cross-fertilization across various disciplines – seem to leave out one of the most obvious features of models: they are designed for a purpose. Therefore I investigated why, while the construction of models is a goal-oriented task with a predefined purpose, the use of models yields so many new ideas in science. This paper presents my conceptual analysis together with a detailed historical case study. The functional design of models forces scientists to explore vigorously older ideas to adapt them: as the lacunae in a functional model are also functional, scientists need to modify older ideas (that were formulated for different purposes) to fit the present functional gaps in their models. As such, they construct new ideas. The detailed historical case study exemplifies this by showing how Pauli’s original suggestion of the neutrino was, in fact, such an adaptation of Rutherford’s earlier idea of the neutron. The present analysis and case study suggest that functional adaptations are salient but often overlooked features of model based investigation.
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:
author
organization
year
type
bookChapter
publication status
published
subject
book title
Model-based reasoning in science and technology : theoretical and cognitive issues
editor
Lorenzo Magnani
series title
SAPERE
pages
449 - 461
publisher
Springer-Verlag
place of publication
Berlin, Germany
ISBN
978-3-642-37427-2
DOI
10.1007/978-3-642-37428-9
language
English
UGent publication?
yes
classification
B2
copyright statement
I have transferred the copyright for this publication to the publisher
VABB id
c:vabb:354539
VABB type
VABB-4
id
3178949
handle
http://hdl.handle.net/1854/LU-3178949
date created
2013-03-29 12:08:14
date last changed
2017-01-02 09:56:18
@incollection{3178949,
  abstract     = {Models have proven themselves to be the key catalyst of many new ideas in science. However, it is not yet fully clarified why models can fulfill such an important heuristic role. The two main reasons stated in the literature --  the mental simulation of various scenarios and the wide cross-fertilization across various disciplines -- seem to leave out one of the most obvious features of models: they are designed for a purpose. Therefore I investigated why, while the construction of models is a goal-oriented task with a predefined purpose, the use of models yields so many new ideas in science. This paper presents my conceptual analysis together with a detailed historical case study.

The functional design of models forces scientists to explore vigorously older ideas to adapt them: as the lacunae in a functional model are also functional, scientists need to modify older ideas (that were formulated for different purposes) to fit the present functional gaps in their models. As such, they construct new ideas. The detailed historical case study exemplifies this by showing how Pauli{\textquoteright}s original suggestion of the neutrino was, in fact, such an adaptation of Rutherford{\textquoteright}s earlier idea of the neutron. The present analysis and case study suggest that functional adaptations are salient but often overlooked features of model based investigation.},
  author       = {Gauderis, Tjerk},
  booktitle    = {Model-based reasoning in science and technology : theoretical and cognitive issues},
  editor       = {Magnani, Lorenzo},
  isbn         = {978-3-642-37427-2},
  language     = {eng},
  pages        = {449--461},
  publisher    = {Springer-Verlag},
  series       = {SAPERE},
  title        = {Pauli's idea of the Neutrino: how models in physics allow to revive old ideas for new proposes},
  url          = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-37428-9},
  year         = {2014},
}

Chicago
Gauderis, Tjerk. 2014. “Pauli’s Idea of the Neutrino: How Models in Physics Allow to Revive Old Ideas for New Proposes.” In Model-based Reasoning in Science and Technology : Theoretical and Cognitive Issues, ed. Lorenzo Magnani, 449–461. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
APA
Gauderis, T. (2014). Pauli’s idea of the Neutrino: how models in physics allow to revive old ideas for new proposes. In Lorenzo Magnani (Ed.), Model-based reasoning in science and technology : theoretical and cognitive issues (pp. 449–461). Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
Vancouver
1.
Gauderis T. Pauli’s idea of the Neutrino: how models in physics allow to revive old ideas for new proposes. In: Magnani L, editor. Model-based reasoning in science and technology : theoretical and cognitive issues. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag; 2014. p. 449–61.
MLA
Gauderis, Tjerk. “Pauli’s Idea of the Neutrino: How Models in Physics Allow to Revive Old Ideas for New Proposes.” Model-based Reasoning in Science and Technology : Theoretical and Cognitive Issues. Ed. Lorenzo Magnani. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag, 2014. 449–461. Print.