Comment on 'Conservation laws of higher order nonlinear PDEs and the variational conservation laws in the class with mixed derivatives'
 Author
 Willy Sarlet (UGent)
 Organization
 Abstract
 In a recent paper (R Narain and A H Kara 2010 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 43 085205), the authors claim to be applying Noether's theorem to higherorder partial differential equations and state that in a large class of examples 'the resultant conserved flows display some previously unknown interesting 'divergence properties' owing to the presence of the mixed derivatives' (citation from their abstract). It turns out that what this obscure sentence is meant to say is that the vector whose divergence must be zero (according to Noether's theorem), turns out to have nonzero divergence and subsequently must be modified to obtain a true conservation law. Clearly this cannot be right: we explain in detail the main source of the error.
Downloads

(...).pdf
 full text
 
 UGent only
 
 
 100.66 KB

commenton2.pdf
 full text
 
 open access
 
 
 110.54 KB
Citation
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication: http://hdl.handle.net/1854/LU1088364
 Chicago
 Sarlet, Willy. 2010. “Comment on ‘Conservation Laws of Higher Order Nonlinear PDEs and the Variational Conservation Laws in the Class with Mixed Derivatives’.” Journal of Physics Amathematical and Theoretical.
 APA
 Sarlet, Willy. (2010). Comment on “Conservation laws of higher order nonlinear PDEs and the variational conservation laws in the class with mixed derivatives.” JOURNAL OF PHYSICS AMATHEMATICAL AND THEORETICAL.
 Vancouver
 1.Sarlet W. Comment on “Conservation laws of higher order nonlinear PDEs and the variational conservation laws in the class with mixed derivatives.”JOURNAL OF PHYSICS AMATHEMATICAL AND THEORETICAL. 2010.
 MLA
 Sarlet, Willy. “Comment on ‘Conservation Laws of Higher Order Nonlinear PDEs and the Variational Conservation Laws in the Class with Mixed Derivatives’.” JOURNAL OF PHYSICS AMATHEMATICAL AND THEORETICAL 2010 : n. pag. Print.
@misc{1088364, abstract = {In a recent paper (R Narain and A H Kara 2010 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 43 085205), the authors claim to be applying Noether's theorem to higherorder partial differential equations and state that in a large class of examples 'the resultant conserved flows display some previously unknown interesting 'divergence properties' owing to the presence of the mixed derivatives' (citation from their abstract). It turns out that what this obscure sentence is meant to say is that the vector whose divergence must be zero (according to Noether's theorem), turns out to have nonzero divergence and subsequently must be modified to obtain a true conservation law. Clearly this cannot be right: we explain in detail the main source of the error.}, articleno = {458001}, author = {Sarlet, Willy}, issn = {17518113}, language = {eng}, number = {45}, pages = {6}, series = {JOURNAL OF PHYSICS AMATHEMATICAL AND THEORETICAL}, title = {Comment on 'Conservation laws of higher order nonlinear PDEs and the variational conservation laws in the class with mixed derivatives'}, url = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/17518113/43/45/458001}, volume = {43}, year = {2010}, }
 Altmetric
 View in Altmetric
 Web of Science
 Times cited: