Dukes and abbots : essays on the economics of estate management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820)
(2025)
- Author
- Sander Berghmans (UGent)
- Promoter
- Thijs Lambrecht (UGent) , Koen Schoors (UGent) and Erik Thoen (UGent)
- Organization
- Abstract
- The historiography concerning the economy of rural societies in the Southern Netherlands—and that of Europe in general—has received significant attention from researchers in recent years. Earlier research on this theme primarily focused on major economic movements such as the evolution of food, labor, and land markets, as well as social phenomena like inequality. While such research is crucial for understanding early modern society, it often lacks deeper insight into the mechanisms behind these evolutions: What drove people in a certain position to make specific economic choices and thus contribute to broader economic processes? This dissertation specifically examines the management (which can be seen as an economic choice) of the estates of large landowners. Large landowners played a crucial role in the early modern economy. These powerful figures and their organizations exerted a disproportionately large socio-economic and political influence on local communities. In this capacity, they could, especially when making similar choices, have a significant impact on how the economy and society took shape. This dissertation, therefore, seeks to answer the question: how did the management of large estates in the Southern Netherlands influence production (processes) and the social relationships that were part of these production processes? In answering this question, three key factors influencing management are considered: the organization of property, the socio-economic environment, and short-term economic fluctuations. This was done through case studies of three large landowners: the Dukes of Arenberg, the Abbey of the Dunes (Roosewalle), and Abbot De Loose of Ename. Based on these cases, I arrived at several important conclusions and contributions to the literature. This dissertation demonstrates that management decisions could have a significant impact on the local population. However, these decisions were made in relation to the local population and could sometimes lead to a form of counterreaction. At the same time, the choices available to landowners were largely path-dependent. Furthermore, this dissertation shows that the direct exploitation of part of the land was more common than previously assumed. Moreover, this dissertation contributes to the field of business economics. It appears that landowners consistently aimed for maximum personal revenue rather than the highest production, which would have been more beneficial for the population. Finally, this dissertation addresses the criticism that research on the principal-agent relationship is ahistorical, acontextual, and static by employing the historical method.
- De geschiedschrijving met betrekking tot de economie van de plattelandsmaatschappijen in de Zuidelijke Nederlanden - en die van Europa in het algemeen - heeft de afgelopen jaren veel aandacht gekregen van onderzoekers. Eerder onderzoek naar dit thema richtte zich voornamelijk op de grotere economische bewegingen zoals de evolutie van voedings-, arbeids- en landmarkten, maar ook op maatschappelijke fenomenen zoals ongelijkheid. Hoewel dergelijk onderzoek van cruciaal belang is om de vroegmoderne maatschappij te begrijpen, ontbreekt vaak een dieper inzicht in de mechanismen achter deze evoluties, of anders gesteld: Wat bracht mensen in een bepaalde positie ertoe om bepaalde economische keuzes te maken en zo bij te dragen aan bredere economische processen? In dit doctoraat wordt specifiek ingegaan op het beheer (dat gezien kan worden als een economische keuze) van de bezittingen van grootgrondbezitters. Grootgrondbezitters speelden namelijk een cruciale rol in de vroegmoderne economie. Deze machtige figuren en instellingen oefenden een buitenproportioneel grote sociaal-economische en politieke invloed uit op lokale gemeenschappen. In deze hoedanigheid konden ze, zeker wanneer ze gelijkaardige keuzes maakten, een belangrijke impact hebben op hoe de economie en maatschappij vorm kregen. Dit doctoraat tracht daarom een antwoord te geven op de vraag: hoe heeft het beheer van grote domeinen in de Zuidelijke Nederlanden de productie(processen) en de sociale relaties, die onderdeel uitmaakten van deze productieprocessen, beïnvloed? Bij het beantwoorden van deze vraag wordt rekening gehouden met drie belangrijke factoren die het beheer beïnvloeden: de organisatie van het bezit, de socio-economische omgeving en de korte termijn economische fluctuaties. Dit gebeurde aan de hand van casestudies van drie grootgrondbezitters: de hertogen van Arenberg, de Duinenabdij (Roosewalle) en abt De Loose van Ename. Op basis van deze cases kwam ik tot een aantal belangrijke conclusies en bijdragen aan de literatuur. Dit proefschrift laat zien dat beheersbeslissingen een grote impact konden hebben op de lokale bevolking. Deze beslissingen werden echter genomen in relatie tot de lokale bevolking en konden soms leiden tot een vorm van tegenreactie. Tegelijkertijd waren de keuzes die de landeigenaars hadden in belangrijke mate padafhankelijk. Verder toont dit proefschrift dat directe exploitatie van een deel van het grondbezit vaker voorkwam dan eerder werd aangenomen. Bovendien draagt dit proefschrift ook bij aan het vakgebied van bedrijfseconomie. Het blijkt dat landgoedeigenaren steeds streefden naar een maximale eigen opbrengst in plaats van de hoogste productie, die voordeliger zou zijn geweest voor de bevolking. Tenslotte pakt deze dissertatie de kritiek aan dat onderzoek naar de principaal-agent relatie ahistorisch, acontextueel en statisch is door het gebruik van de historische methode.
Downloads
-
(...).pdf
- full text (Published version)
- |
- UGent only
- |
- |
- 3.72 MB
Citation
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication: http://hdl.handle.net/1854/LU-01JPJT1YZ0PE9Q9FV7H782639Y
- MLA
- Berghmans, Sander. Dukes and Abbots : Essays on the Economics of Estate Management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820). Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy, 2025.
- APA
- Berghmans, S. (2025). Dukes and abbots : essays on the economics of estate management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820). Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy, Ghent, Belgium.
- Chicago author-date
- Berghmans, Sander. 2025. “Dukes and Abbots : Essays on the Economics of Estate Management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820).” Ghent, Belgium: Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy.
- Chicago author-date (all authors)
- Berghmans, Sander. 2025. “Dukes and Abbots : Essays on the Economics of Estate Management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820).” Ghent, Belgium: Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy.
- Vancouver
- 1.Berghmans S. Dukes and abbots : essays on the economics of estate management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820). [Ghent, Belgium]: Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy; 2025.
- IEEE
- [1]S. Berghmans, “Dukes and abbots : essays on the economics of estate management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820),” Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy, Ghent, Belgium, 2025.
@phdthesis{01JPJT1YZ0PE9Q9FV7H782639Y,
abstract = {{The historiography concerning the economy of rural societies in the Southern Netherlands—and that of Europe in general—has received significant attention from researchers in recent years. Earlier research on this theme primarily focused on major economic movements such as the evolution of food, labor, and land markets, as well as social phenomena like inequality. While such research is crucial for understanding early modern society, it often lacks deeper insight into the mechanisms behind these evolutions: What drove people in a certain position to make specific economic choices and thus contribute to broader economic processes? This dissertation specifically examines the management (which can be seen as an economic choice) of the estates of large landowners. Large landowners played a crucial role in the early modern economy. These powerful figures and their organizations exerted a disproportionately large socio-economic and political influence on local communities. In this capacity, they could, especially when making similar choices, have a significant impact on how the economy and society took shape. This dissertation, therefore, seeks to answer the question: how did the management of large estates in the Southern Netherlands influence production (processes) and the social relationships that were part of these production processes? In answering this question, three key factors influencing management are considered: the organization of property, the socio-economic environment, and short-term economic fluctuations.
This was done through case studies of three large landowners: the Dukes of Arenberg, the Abbey of the Dunes (Roosewalle), and Abbot De Loose of Ename. Based on these cases, I arrived at several important conclusions and contributions to the literature. This dissertation demonstrates that management decisions could have a significant impact on the local population. However, these decisions were made in relation to the local population and could sometimes lead to a form of counterreaction. At the same time, the choices available to landowners were largely path-dependent. Furthermore, this dissertation shows that the direct exploitation of part of the land was more common than previously assumed. Moreover, this dissertation contributes to the field of business economics. It appears that landowners consistently aimed for maximum personal revenue rather than the highest production, which would have been more beneficial for the population. Finally, this dissertation addresses the criticism that research on the principal-agent relationship is ahistorical, acontextual, and static by employing the historical method.}},
author = {{Berghmans, Sander}},
language = {{eng}},
pages = {{XX, 216}},
publisher = {{Ghent University. Faculty of Arts and Philosophy}},
school = {{Ghent University}},
title = {{Dukes and abbots : essays on the economics of estate management in the Southern Netherlands (ca. 1600-1820)}},
year = {{2025}},
}