Advanced search
1 file | 81.88 KB Add to list

When high right-wing authoritarians report elevated empathy toward a black woman victim of police violence : 'inclusive victimhood consciousness' from police mistreatment experiences

(2024) PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE. 14(5). p.302-314
Author
Organization
Abstract
Objective: Outgroup empathy deficit research suggests that White U.S. citizens-especially those most prone to prejudice-should report minimal empathy for Black victims of police violence. We propose that this oft-cited phenomena is not inevitable, and the police-related experiences of those White individuals must be considered. To address this issue, we considered empathy toward a Black versus White woman victim of a fatal police shooting. We were particularly interested in identifying factors that might eliminate outgroup empathy deficits. Method: Two hundred and thirty White MTurk participants completed a right-wing authoritarianism (RWA) measure and reported the extent that they experienced police mistreatment. They were randomly assigned to read about a deadly White policeman shooting of a Black or White woman and reported the extent they believed Black people experienced unfair police mistreatment, their victim-directed empathy, and their compassion for her family. Results: There was clear evidence of inclusive victimhood consciousness (i.e., acknowledging that one's personal experiences are like those of an outgroup). Specifically, in the Black (but not White) victim condition, greater perceived personal police mistreatment predicted elevated perceived police mistreatment of Black individuals, which in turn was linked to heightened victim-directed empathy and family-directed compassion. Critically important, these effects were limited to high RWA participants. The Victim Race x Personal Police Mistreatment interaction was not significant for low RWA participants. Conclusions: In sum, among highly authoritarian White participants, police mistreatment experiences were positively associated with empathy for a Black woman victim of a deadly police shooting and compassion for her family.
Keywords
right-wing authoritarianism, Black women, victim, police, racial, prejudice, SOCIAL-DOMINANCE ORIENTATION, LIVES MATTER, ATTITUDES, RACE, PREJUDICE, AMERICANS, CONTACT, IMPACT, CATEGORIZATION, IDENTIFICATION

Downloads

  • POV 2024 IN PRESS.docx
    • full text (Accepted manuscript)
    • |
    • open access
    • |
    • Word
    • |
    • 81.88 KB

Citation

Please use this url to cite or link to this publication:

MLA
Johnson, James, et al. “When High Right-Wing Authoritarians Report Elevated Empathy toward a Black Woman Victim of Police Violence : ‘inclusive Victimhood Consciousness’ from Police Mistreatment Experiences.” PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE, vol. 14, no. 5, 2024, pp. 302–14, doi:10.1037/vio0000494.
APA
Johnson, J., Sattler, D. N., Ginther, K., Van Hiel, A., Dierckx, K., Luo, S., & Vezzali, L. (2024). When high right-wing authoritarians report elevated empathy toward a black woman victim of police violence : “inclusive victimhood consciousness” from police mistreatment experiences. PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE, 14(5), 302–314. https://doi.org/10.1037/vio0000494
Chicago author-date
Johnson, James, David N. Sattler, Katie Ginther, Alain Van Hiel, Kim Dierckx, Shanhong Luo, and Loris Vezzali. 2024. “When High Right-Wing Authoritarians Report Elevated Empathy toward a Black Woman Victim of Police Violence : ‘inclusive Victimhood Consciousness’ from Police Mistreatment Experiences.” PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE 14 (5): 302–14. https://doi.org/10.1037/vio0000494.
Chicago author-date (all authors)
Johnson, James, David N. Sattler, Katie Ginther, Alain Van Hiel, Kim Dierckx, Shanhong Luo, and Loris Vezzali. 2024. “When High Right-Wing Authoritarians Report Elevated Empathy toward a Black Woman Victim of Police Violence : ‘inclusive Victimhood Consciousness’ from Police Mistreatment Experiences.” PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE 14 (5): 302–314. doi:10.1037/vio0000494.
Vancouver
1.
Johnson J, Sattler DN, Ginther K, Van Hiel A, Dierckx K, Luo S, et al. When high right-wing authoritarians report elevated empathy toward a black woman victim of police violence : “inclusive victimhood consciousness” from police mistreatment experiences. PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE. 2024;14(5):302–14.
IEEE
[1]
J. Johnson et al., “When high right-wing authoritarians report elevated empathy toward a black woman victim of police violence : ‘inclusive victimhood consciousness’ from police mistreatment experiences,” PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 302–314, 2024.
@article{01JP84MVK706EZ4BHRYC4D8006,
  abstract     = {{Objective: Outgroup empathy deficit research suggests that White U.S. citizens-especially those most prone to prejudice-should report minimal empathy for Black victims of police violence. We propose that this oft-cited phenomena is not inevitable, and the police-related experiences of those White individuals must be considered. To address this issue, we considered empathy toward a Black versus White woman victim of a fatal police shooting. We were particularly interested in identifying factors that might eliminate outgroup empathy deficits. Method: Two hundred and thirty White MTurk participants completed a right-wing authoritarianism (RWA) measure and reported the extent that they experienced police mistreatment. They were randomly assigned to read about a deadly White policeman shooting of a Black or White woman and reported the extent they believed Black people experienced unfair police mistreatment, their victim-directed empathy, and their compassion for her family. Results: There was clear evidence of inclusive victimhood consciousness (i.e., acknowledging that one's personal experiences are like those of an outgroup). Specifically, in the Black (but not White) victim condition, greater perceived personal police mistreatment predicted elevated perceived police mistreatment of Black individuals, which in turn was linked to heightened victim-directed empathy and family-directed compassion. Critically important, these effects were limited to high RWA participants. The Victim Race x Personal Police Mistreatment interaction was not significant for low RWA participants. Conclusions: In sum, among highly authoritarian White participants, police mistreatment experiences were positively associated with empathy for a Black woman victim of a deadly police shooting and compassion for her family.}},
  author       = {{Johnson, James and Sattler, David N. and Ginther, Katie and Van Hiel, Alain and Dierckx, Kim and Luo, Shanhong and Vezzali, Loris}},
  issn         = {{2152-0828}},
  journal      = {{PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE}},
  keywords     = {{right-wing authoritarianism,Black women,victim,police,racial,prejudice,SOCIAL-DOMINANCE ORIENTATION,LIVES MATTER,ATTITUDES,RACE,PREJUDICE,AMERICANS,CONTACT,IMPACT,CATEGORIZATION,IDENTIFICATION}},
  language     = {{eng}},
  number       = {{5}},
  pages        = {{302--314}},
  title        = {{When high right-wing authoritarians report elevated empathy toward a black woman victim of police violence : 'inclusive victimhood consciousness' from police mistreatment experiences}},
  url          = {{http://doi.org/10.1037/vio0000494}},
  volume       = {{14}},
  year         = {{2024}},
}

Altmetric
View in Altmetric
Web of Science
Times cited: