
Assessing and improving the robustness of Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension for inverting time-domain electromagnetic data : introducing a new threshold procedure
- Author
- Arsalan Ahmed (UGent) , Lukas Aigner, Hadrien Michel, Wouter Deleersnyder (UGent) , David Dudal (UGent) , Adrian Flores Orozco and Thomas Hermans (UGent)
- Organization
- Project
- Abstract
- Understanding the subsurface is of prime importance for many geological and hydrogeological applications. Geophysical methods offer an economical alternative for investigating the subsurface compared to costly borehole investigations. However, geophysical results are commonly obtained through deterministic inversion of data whose solution is non-unique. Alternatively, stochastic inversions investigate the full uncertainty range of the obtained models, yet are computationally more expensive. In this research, we investigate the robustness of the recently introduced Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension (BEL1D) for the stochastic inversion of time-domain electromagnetic data (TDEM). First, we analyse the impact of the accuracy of the numerical forward solver on the posterior distribution, and derive a compromise between accuracy and computational time. We also introduce a threshold-rejection method based on the data misfit after the first iteration, circumventing the need for further BEL1D iterations. Moreover, we analyse the impact of the prior-model space on the results. We apply the new BEL1D with a threshold approach on field data collected in the Luy River catchment (Vietnam) to delineate saltwater intrusions. Our results show that the proper selection of time and space discretization is essential for limiting the computational cost while maintaining the accuracy of the posterior estimation. The selection of the prior distribution has a direct impact on fitting the observed data and is crucial for a realistic uncertainty quantification. The application of BEL1D for stochastic TDEM inversion is an efficient approach, as it allows us to estimate the uncertainty at a limited cost.
- Keywords
- Water Science and Technology, Aquatic Science, Geography, Planning and Development, Biochemistry, uncertainty, saltwater intrusion, TDEM, BEL1D, SimPEG, UNCERTAINTY QUANTIFICATION, INVERSE PROBLEMS, HYDROGEOLOGY, RESISTIVITY, SIMULATION, PREDICTION
Downloads
-
Ahmed etal 2024 water.pdf
- full text (Published version)
- |
- open access
- |
- |
- 6.33 MB
Citation
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication: http://hdl.handle.net/1854/LU-01HV3DG00AQKFZMRH8B9KSP1MZ
- MLA
- Ahmed, Arsalan, et al. “Assessing and Improving the Robustness of Bayesian Evidential Learning in One Dimension for Inverting Time-Domain Electromagnetic Data : Introducing a New Threshold Procedure.” WATER, vol. 16, no. 7, 2024, doi:10.3390/w16071056.
- APA
- Ahmed, A., Aigner, L., Michel, H., Deleersnyder, W., Dudal, D., Flores Orozco, A., & Hermans, T. (2024). Assessing and improving the robustness of Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension for inverting time-domain electromagnetic data : introducing a new threshold procedure. WATER, 16(7). https://doi.org/10.3390/w16071056
- Chicago author-date
- Ahmed, Arsalan, Lukas Aigner, Hadrien Michel, Wouter Deleersnyder, David Dudal, Adrian Flores Orozco, and Thomas Hermans. 2024. “Assessing and Improving the Robustness of Bayesian Evidential Learning in One Dimension for Inverting Time-Domain Electromagnetic Data : Introducing a New Threshold Procedure.” WATER 16 (7). https://doi.org/10.3390/w16071056.
- Chicago author-date (all authors)
- Ahmed, Arsalan, Lukas Aigner, Hadrien Michel, Wouter Deleersnyder, David Dudal, Adrian Flores Orozco, and Thomas Hermans. 2024. “Assessing and Improving the Robustness of Bayesian Evidential Learning in One Dimension for Inverting Time-Domain Electromagnetic Data : Introducing a New Threshold Procedure.” WATER 16 (7). doi:10.3390/w16071056.
- Vancouver
- 1.Ahmed A, Aigner L, Michel H, Deleersnyder W, Dudal D, Flores Orozco A, et al. Assessing and improving the robustness of Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension for inverting time-domain electromagnetic data : introducing a new threshold procedure. WATER. 2024;16(7).
- IEEE
- [1]A. Ahmed et al., “Assessing and improving the robustness of Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension for inverting time-domain electromagnetic data : introducing a new threshold procedure,” WATER, vol. 16, no. 7, 2024.
@article{01HV3DG00AQKFZMRH8B9KSP1MZ, abstract = {{Understanding the subsurface is of prime importance for many geological and hydrogeological applications. Geophysical methods offer an economical alternative for investigating the subsurface compared to costly borehole investigations. However, geophysical results are commonly obtained through deterministic inversion of data whose solution is non-unique. Alternatively, stochastic inversions investigate the full uncertainty range of the obtained models, yet are computationally more expensive. In this research, we investigate the robustness of the recently introduced Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension (BEL1D) for the stochastic inversion of time-domain electromagnetic data (TDEM). First, we analyse the impact of the accuracy of the numerical forward solver on the posterior distribution, and derive a compromise between accuracy and computational time. We also introduce a threshold-rejection method based on the data misfit after the first iteration, circumventing the need for further BEL1D iterations. Moreover, we analyse the impact of the prior-model space on the results. We apply the new BEL1D with a threshold approach on field data collected in the Luy River catchment (Vietnam) to delineate saltwater intrusions. Our results show that the proper selection of time and space discretization is essential for limiting the computational cost while maintaining the accuracy of the posterior estimation. The selection of the prior distribution has a direct impact on fitting the observed data and is crucial for a realistic uncertainty quantification. The application of BEL1D for stochastic TDEM inversion is an efficient approach, as it allows us to estimate the uncertainty at a limited cost.}}, articleno = {{1056}}, author = {{Ahmed, Arsalan and Aigner, Lukas and Michel, Hadrien and Deleersnyder, Wouter and Dudal, David and Flores Orozco, Adrian and Hermans, Thomas}}, issn = {{2073-4441}}, journal = {{WATER}}, keywords = {{Water Science and Technology,Aquatic Science,Geography, Planning and Development,Biochemistry,uncertainty,saltwater intrusion,TDEM,BEL1D,SimPEG,UNCERTAINTY QUANTIFICATION,INVERSE PROBLEMS,HYDROGEOLOGY,RESISTIVITY,SIMULATION,PREDICTION}}, language = {{eng}}, number = {{7}}, pages = {{25}}, title = {{Assessing and improving the robustness of Bayesian evidential learning in one dimension for inverting time-domain electromagnetic data : introducing a new threshold procedure}}, url = {{http://doi.org/10.3390/w16071056}}, volume = {{16}}, year = {{2024}}, }
- Altmetric
- View in Altmetric
- Web of Science
- Times cited: