International comparison exercise for biological dosimetry after exposures with neutrons performed at two irradiation facilities as part of the BALANCE project
- Author
- David Endesfelder, Ulrike Kulka, Martin Bucher, Ulrich Giesen, Guy Garty, Christina Beinke, Matthias Port, Gaetan Gruel, Eric Gregoire, Georgia Terzoudi, Sotiria Triantopoulou, Elizabeth A. Ainsbury, Jayne Moquet, Mingzhu Sun, María Jesús Prieto, Mercedes Moreno Domene, Joan-Francesc Barquinero, Monica Pujol-Canadell, Anne Vral (UGent) , Ans Baeyens (UGent) , Andrzej Wojcik and Ursula Oestreicher
- Organization
- Abstract
- In the case of a radiological or nuclear event, biological dosimetry can be an important tool to support clinical decision-making. During a nuclear event, individuals might be exposed to a mixed field of neutrons and photons. The composition of the field and the neutron energy spectrum influence the degree of damage to the chromosomes. During the transatlantic BALANCE project, an exposure similar to a Hiroshima-like device at a distance of 1.5 km from the epicenter was simulated and biological dosimetry based on dicentric chromosomes was performed to evaluate the participants ability to discover unknown doses and to test the influence of differences in neutron spectra. In a first step, calibration curves were established by irradiating blood samples with 5 doses in the range of 0 Gy to 4 Gy at two different facilities in Germany (PTB) and USA (CINF). The samples were sent to eight participating laboratories from the RENEB network and dicentric chromosomes were scored by each participant. Next, blood samples were irradiated with 4 blind doses in each of the two facilities and sent to the participants to provide dose estimates based on the established calibration curves. Manual and semi-automatic scoring of dicentric chromosomes were evaluated for their applicability to neutron exposures. Moreover, the biological effectiveness of the neutrons from the two irradiation facilities was compared. The calibration curves from samples irradiated at CINF showed a 1.4 times higher biological effectiveness compared to samples irradiated at PTB. For manual scoring of dicentric chromosomes, the doses of the test samples were mostly successfully resolved based on the calibration curves established during the project. For semi-automatic scoring, the dose estimation for the test samples was less successful. Doses >2 Gy in the calibration curves revealed non-linear associations between dose and dispersion index of the dicentric counts, especially for manual scoring. The differences in the biological effectiveness between the irradiation facilities suggested that the neutron energy spectrum can have a strong impact on the dicentric counts.
- Keywords
- Genetics (clinical), Genetics, Molecular Biology
Downloads
-
Cyto Gen Research 2023 Balance paper .pdf
- full text (Accepted manuscript)
- |
- open access
- |
- |
- 4.47 MB
-
(...).pdf
- full text (Published version)
- |
- UGent only
- |
- |
- 1.18 MB
Citation
Please use this url to cite or link to this publication: http://hdl.handle.net/1854/LU-01GZ8RYAX7KDME0VQB902Q0C51
- MLA
- Endesfelder, David, et al. “International Comparison Exercise for Biological Dosimetry after Exposures with Neutrons Performed at Two Irradiation Facilities as Part of the BALANCE Project.” CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH, vol. 163, no. 3–4, S. Karger AG, 2023, pp. 163–77, doi:10.1159/000530728.
- APA
- Endesfelder, D., Kulka, U., Bucher, M., Giesen, U., Garty, G., Beinke, C., … Oestreicher, U. (2023). International comparison exercise for biological dosimetry after exposures with neutrons performed at two irradiation facilities as part of the BALANCE project. CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH, 163(3–4), 163–177. https://doi.org/10.1159/000530728
- Chicago author-date
- Endesfelder, David, Ulrike Kulka, Martin Bucher, Ulrich Giesen, Guy Garty, Christina Beinke, Matthias Port, et al. 2023. “International Comparison Exercise for Biological Dosimetry after Exposures with Neutrons Performed at Two Irradiation Facilities as Part of the BALANCE Project.” CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH 163 (3–4): 163–77. https://doi.org/10.1159/000530728.
- Chicago author-date (all authors)
- Endesfelder, David, Ulrike Kulka, Martin Bucher, Ulrich Giesen, Guy Garty, Christina Beinke, Matthias Port, Gaetan Gruel, Eric Gregoire, Georgia Terzoudi, Sotiria Triantopoulou, Elizabeth A. Ainsbury, Jayne Moquet, Mingzhu Sun, María Jesús Prieto, Mercedes Moreno Domene, Joan-Francesc Barquinero, Monica Pujol-Canadell, Anne Vral, Ans Baeyens, Andrzej Wojcik, and Ursula Oestreicher. 2023. “International Comparison Exercise for Biological Dosimetry after Exposures with Neutrons Performed at Two Irradiation Facilities as Part of the BALANCE Project.” CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH 163 (3–4): 163–177. doi:10.1159/000530728.
- Vancouver
- 1.Endesfelder D, Kulka U, Bucher M, Giesen U, Garty G, Beinke C, et al. International comparison exercise for biological dosimetry after exposures with neutrons performed at two irradiation facilities as part of the BALANCE project. CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH. 2023;163(3–4):163–77.
- IEEE
- [1]D. Endesfelder et al., “International comparison exercise for biological dosimetry after exposures with neutrons performed at two irradiation facilities as part of the BALANCE project,” CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH, vol. 163, no. 3–4, pp. 163–177, 2023.
@article{01GZ8RYAX7KDME0VQB902Q0C51, abstract = {{In the case of a radiological or nuclear event, biological dosimetry can be an important tool to support clinical decision-making. During a nuclear event, individuals might be exposed to a mixed field of neutrons and photons. The composition of the field and the neutron energy spectrum influence the degree of damage to the chromosomes. During the transatlantic BALANCE project, an exposure similar to a Hiroshima-like device at a distance of 1.5 km from the epicenter was simulated and biological dosimetry based on dicentric chromosomes was performed to evaluate the participants ability to discover unknown doses and to test the influence of differences in neutron spectra. In a first step, calibration curves were established by irradiating blood samples with 5 doses in the range of 0 Gy to 4 Gy at two different facilities in Germany (PTB) and USA (CINF). The samples were sent to eight participating laboratories from the RENEB network and dicentric chromosomes were scored by each participant. Next, blood samples were irradiated with 4 blind doses in each of the two facilities and sent to the participants to provide dose estimates based on the established calibration curves. Manual and semi-automatic scoring of dicentric chromosomes were evaluated for their applicability to neutron exposures. Moreover, the biological effectiveness of the neutrons from the two irradiation facilities was compared. The calibration curves from samples irradiated at CINF showed a 1.4 times higher biological effectiveness compared to samples irradiated at PTB. For manual scoring of dicentric chromosomes, the doses of the test samples were mostly successfully resolved based on the calibration curves established during the project. For semi-automatic scoring, the dose estimation for the test samples was less successful. Doses >2 Gy in the calibration curves revealed non-linear associations between dose and dispersion index of the dicentric counts, especially for manual scoring. The differences in the biological effectiveness between the irradiation facilities suggested that the neutron energy spectrum can have a strong impact on the dicentric counts.}}, author = {{Endesfelder, David and Kulka, Ulrike and Bucher, Martin and Giesen, Ulrich and Garty, Guy and Beinke, Christina and Port, Matthias and Gruel, Gaetan and Gregoire, Eric and Terzoudi, Georgia and Triantopoulou, Sotiria and Ainsbury, Elizabeth A. and Moquet, Jayne and Sun, Mingzhu and Prieto, María Jesús and Moreno Domene, Mercedes and Barquinero, Joan-Francesc and Pujol-Canadell, Monica and Vral, Anne and Baeyens, Ans and Wojcik, Andrzej and Oestreicher, Ursula}}, issn = {{1424-8581}}, journal = {{CYTOGENETIC AND GENOME RESEARCH}}, keywords = {{Genetics (clinical),Genetics,Molecular Biology}}, language = {{eng}}, number = {{3-4}}, pages = {{163--177}}, publisher = {{S. Karger AG}}, title = {{International comparison exercise for biological dosimetry after exposures with neutrons performed at two irradiation facilities as part of the BALANCE project}}, url = {{http://doi.org/10.1159/000530728}}, volume = {{163}}, year = {{2023}}, }
- Altmetric
- View in Altmetric
- Web of Science
- Times cited: